You found the house. You're already mentally arranging furniture. Then the inspection report lands in your inbox: 47 pages of findings, photos, and technical language that might as well be written in code.
Here's the truth most agents won't tell you: not everything in an inspection report is a dealbreaker, but some things absolutely are. The skill is knowing which is which before you've emotionally committed another $10,000 in negotiations.
After guiding buyers through hundreds of inspection reports in Colorado, I've learned that the difference between a smart purchase and a money pit often comes down to understanding 10 specific red flags.
The Big 3: Structural Red Flags That Can Cost $50,000+
These are the findings that should stop you in your tracks. Not "let's negotiate," but "let's think very carefully about whether this house is worth the risk."
1. Foundation Cracks and Settlement Issues
Colorado's expansive clay soils are notorious for foundation problems. A foundation crack wider than 1/4 inch, stair-step cracks in brick, or doors and windows that don't close properly are all warning signs. Foundation repairs in the Denver metro area typically run between $8,000 and $30,000, but severe cases can exceed $75,000.
What to ask your inspector: "Is this crack active or dormant? What's causing the movement?"
2. Roof Issues Beyond Normal Wear
In Colorado, our intense UV exposure and hail seasons are brutal on roofs. A roof with 2-3 years of life left is negotiable. A roof with active leaks, sagging sections, or structural damage to the decking is a different conversation entirely. Average roof replacement costs in Colorado range from $12,000 to $25,000 for a typical single-family home.
The Colorado-specific factor: Check for hail damage claims in the seller's disclosure. A roof that's been patched multiple times may not last as long as its age suggests.
3. Major Water Intrusion
Water stains on ceilings, musty smells in basements, or efflorescence (white mineral deposits) on concrete walls all point to water problems. In Colorado's semi-arid climate, buyers sometimes underestimate water issues, thinking "it doesn't rain that much." But our spring snowmelt and summer thunderstorms can overwhelm drainage systems fast.
Red flag multiplier: If you see evidence of water intrusion AND the sellers have recently painted the basement, dig deeper. Fresh paint in basements is sometimes a cover-up.
The Hidden 4: Systems That Fail Quietly
These issues won't collapse your house, but they'll drain your bank account steadily if you don't catch them.
4. Electrical Panel Problems
Federal Pacific and Zinsco panels are immediate red flags. These panels, common in homes built between 1950-1990, have documented failure rates and many insurance companies won't cover homes with them. Panel replacement runs $2,000-$4,000, but if the home needs rewiring, you're looking at $8,000-$15,000.
What brands should I watch out for in electrical panels?
Federal Pacific Electric (FPE) "Stab-Lok" panels and Zinsco panels are the two most problematic. Both have been linked to house fires due to breakers that don't trip properly. If your inspection report mentions either brand, get an electrician's assessment before proceeding.
5. HVAC at End of Life
Furnaces and AC units last 15-20 years on average. A 17-year-old system isn't a dealbreaker, but you should budget for replacement within 3-5 years. In Colorado, where you'll use both heating and cooling extensively, replacing an HVAC system runs $8,000-$15,000.
How can I tell if the HVAC system was properly maintained?
Ask to see maintenance records. Look at the furnace filter during the inspection. If it's caked with dust, that's a sign of deferred maintenance. Also check the condenser unit outside for bent fins, debris, or signs of damage from hail.
6. Plumbing Material Concerns
Polybutylene pipes (gray plastic, common 1978-1995) and galvanized steel pipes in older homes are ticking time bombs. Polybutylene deteriorates from the inside and can fail suddenly. Galvanized pipes corrode, restricting water flow and eventually leaking. Repiping a house typically costs $4,000-$10,000 depending on size and accessibility.
7. Sewer Line Condition
Here's a red flag most buyers don't think to check: the sewer line. Standard home inspections don't include sewer scope, but in Colorado homes over 30 years old, you should add one for $150-$300. Root intrusion, bellied pipes, and clay tile deterioration are common. Sewer line replacement can run $5,000-$20,000.
The Sneaky 3: Issues That Seem Minor But Aren't
8. Signs of Pest Activity
Termites, carpenter ants, and powder post beetles can cause structural damage that isn't immediately visible. Small piles of sawdust-like material, mud tubes on foundation walls, or wood that sounds hollow when tapped are all warning signs. Treatment costs are manageable ($500-$2,500), but repairing structural damage can cost tens of thousands.
Should I get a separate pest inspection?
Yes, especially for homes with crawl spaces, lots of wood-to-ground contact, or any signs of previous pest activity. Most general home inspectors aren't pest specialists. A dedicated pest inspection costs $75-$150 and can save you from a nightmare scenario.
9. Improper DIY Work
Unpermitted additions, creative electrical wiring, and amateur plumbing are everywhere in Colorado's housing stock. Signs include: electrical outlets that aren't grounded, deck attachments that don't meet code, and additions that feel "off" in quality. The cost to remediate depends on the scope, but bringing unpermitted work up to code often costs more than doing it right the first time.
10. Environmental Hazards
Colorado has elevated radon levels compared to national averages. About 50% of homes tested in Colorado have radon levels above the EPA action level of 4.0 pCi/L. A radon mitigation system costs $800-$1,500 to install. Lead paint (in homes built before 1978) and asbestos (common in older insulation, flooring, and siding) are additional concerns that may require professional testing.
How to Use This Information in Negotiations
Here's where strategy matters. Not every issue deserves the same response.
Walk away when: You find multiple major structural issues, the seller won't allow additional inspections, or the repair costs exceed what you can comfortably afford post-purchase.
Negotiate hard when: You find one significant system issue (roof, HVAC, plumbing) that has clear repair costs. Get contractor quotes, not guesses.
Accept and budget when: The issues are age-related and expected, like an HVAC system with 3-5 years of life left. These aren't surprises; they're normal homeownership costs.
What if the seller won't negotiate on repairs?
In Colorado's current market, sellers sometimes resist repair requests. Your options: ask for a price reduction instead of repairs, request a credit at closing for you to complete repairs yourself, or decide if the home is still worth it at the current price. Sometimes walking away is the right answer, even if it's painful.
The Blue Pebble Approach to Inspections
Most agents show up to inspection day, chat with the inspector, and forward you the report with "let me know if you have questions."
That's not how we work. I'm reading that report before you are. I'm identifying which findings are deal-relevant and which are maintenance items. I'm researching repair costs specific to your situation. When we talk about the inspection, you're getting analysis, not just information.
Because a 47-page report is useless if you don't know what it means for your decision.
Key Takeaways
- Foundation, roof, and water intrusion are the three most expensive red flags, with potential costs exceeding $50,000 for severe issues.
- Colorado's expansive soils make foundation issues more common here than in many other markets. Always ask about soil conditions.
- Federal Pacific and Zinsco electrical panels are immediate red flags that require professional evaluation before purchase.
- Sewer scope inspections cost $150-$300 and can prevent $20,000 surprises in older homes.
- 50% of Colorado homes test above EPA action levels for radon. Budget $800-$1,500 for mitigation if needed.
- Not everything in an inspection report is a dealbreaker. The skill is distinguishing major issues from normal maintenance.
- Get contractor quotes for specific repairs rather than relying on general estimates during negotiations.
Ready to navigate your next home inspection with confidence? Let's talk about what you're looking for and how to evaluate properties with clear eyes.
Not sure if you're ready to buy? Take our buyer readiness quiz to find out where you stand.